Bulletin #725






5 December 2016
Grenoble, France


Dear Colleagues and Friends of CEIMSA,

We have entered a critical moment in US history, where ‘business as usual’ has lost its attraction for most of us. The multiple crises are a loud knock on the door, and only the most obtuse residents of our planet are able to ignore it. The ratio between political ambitions and common sense seems to be inverse today, and the murderous compromises made by those at the top have become visible to all. Even their well-armed bodyguards cannot shelter them from the truth. They will wither and die for their crimes against humanity, and no one will regret their demise, not even their most intimate friends and family.


Fernand Braudel, social historian and author of the trilogy, Civilization & Capitalism, 15th – 18th Century, wrote in the Preface of Volume One, which he entitled “The Structures of Everyday Life: the limits of the possible,” that in this study of the pre-industrial world, he will attempt to describe the historical context in which there exists a limit, “a ceiling which restricts all human life, containing it within a frontier of varying outline, one which is hard to reach and harder still to cross . . . . This is the border which in every age, even our own, separates the possible from the impossible, what can be done with a little effort from what cannot be done at all. In the past, the border line was imposed by inadequate food supplies, a population that was too big or too small for its resources, low productivity of labor, and the as yet slow progress in controlling nature. Between the fifteenth and the eighteenth century, these constraints hardly changed at all. And men did not even explore the limits of what was possible.”(p.27)


With an enriched understanding of social context, however, the historian is able to perceive a social dynamic at play, even centuries ago. 


[T]he co-existence of the upper and lower levels [of society] forces upon the historian an illuminating dialectic. How can one understand the towns without understanding the countryside, money without barter, the varieties of poverty without the varieties of luxury, the white bread of the rich without the black bread of the poor?(p.29)


Braudel’s extraordinary finding is that ordinary people have had more influence in their societies than is commonly acknowledged. Only a context-rich perception of society is able to detect this and, of course, to take advantage of it.


The 9 items below offer CEIMSA readers insights into the mass mobilization now underway in our rapidly changing consumer society and the possible trajectory to where this popular movement will lead us.




Francis Feeley


Professor emeritus of American Studies

University Grenoble-Alpes

Director of Research

University of Paris-Nanterre

Center for the Advanced Study of American Institutions and Social Movements

The University of California-San Diego

















The People's Tribunal on the Iraq War








Fake News List Death Knell for MSM-Paul Craig Roberts



(41 min. video)

by Greg Hunter





From: News From Underground

Subject: [MCM] US journalists and profs who speak out on RT are getting BLACKLISTED



 Washington Post Reporter Spreads Blacklist of Independent Journalist Sites

U.S. Journalists and Professors Appearing on RT America Get Blacklisted


by Pam Martens and Russ Martens: December 2, 2016


NYU Professor Mark Crispin Miller Is Interviewed on RT Television

NYU Professor Mark Crispin Miller Is Interviewed on RT Television

Some independent journalists and university professors in the United States who have appeared on RT television to criticize either runaway corruption on Wall Street or in Washington, have landed on two newly created blacklists. RT is a Russian state-financed news network formerly known as Russia Today. Its English-language RT America unit broadcasts from Washington, D.C.

A shadowy group called PropOrNot, that has not disclosed either its funders or its principals, has created a blacklist of 200 independent media web sites that it is calling tools of Russia. On the list are some of the most popular and widely read alternative media outlets like Naked Capitalism, Truthout and Truthdig, which regularly carry articles by some of the most knowledgeable and informed voices in America. Another popular site, CounterPunch, was originally on the list but has now been removed following what PropOrNot calls a “constructive conversation.” Reporter Craig Timberg of the Washington Post has come under withering criticism for amplifying the McCarthyite blacklist in a Thanksgiving Day article.


Equally disturbing, 200 university and college professors have been placed on a new Professor Watchlist being operated by Turning Point USA, a right-wing nonprofit run by 23-year old Charlie Kirk who spoke this year at the Republican National Convention. Kirk has raised well over $1 million from conservatives to spread the “free markets/small government” mantra at high school and university campuses (never mind that Wall Street’s “free markets” are just as corrupt today as they were heading into the 2008 epic financial crash).


In 2012, Kirk wrote an opinion piece for Breitbart News suggesting that Paul Krugman’s ideas should be replaced in high school classrooms by those of the Cato Institute – a nonprofit secretly owned in part by the Koch brothers for decades. (Such ideas will land one on the fast-track to big money from the right wing in America.) Steve Bannon, the former Executive Chairman of Breitbart News Network and anti-liberal propaganda filmmaker extraordinaire, has been named by Donald Trump as his Senior Counselor and Chief Strategist in the White House.


Yves Smith, the founder and widely respected writer at Naked Capitalism has appeared on RT television on several occasions. In the interview featured below from 2010, she was afforded the time to make her brilliantly cogent points on the systemic corruption on Wall Street that has yet to be remedied despite the greatest financial crash since the Great Depression. In 2011, Smith alerted her readers that she was going to be appearing on RT America, noting that she “seemed to be banned from US TV channels, but the flip side is this was a much more substantive conversation than you’d find on the usual suspects here.” Indeed, RT America has allowed independent journalists and professors adequate time to make detailed arguments against establishment group-think in America, something that is regularly lacking on corporate-controlled news media in the U.S.

Another independent journalist landing on PropOrNot’s blacklist is Paul Craig Roberts, the former Assistant Secretary of the Treasury for Economic Policy under President Ronald Reagan, a former Associate Editor of the Wall Street Journal and a former columnist at BusinessWeek. In this segment on RT television, Roberts states that the “political system in the United States is as corrupt as it is integrant.” In another appearance on RT, Roberts spoke favorably of Senator Bernie Sanders, stating that “he has independence” and that the special interest groups “don’t like candidates who think for themselves.”


The long-tenured and widely respected Professor of Media, Culture and Communication at New York University, Mark Crispin Miller, has landed on the Professor Watchlist. In this RT interview, Miller called U.S. media a “disgrace,” adding that the quality of journalistic material is “embarrassingly low.” Miller went on to characterize U.S. media as a “cartel,” stating that “we have a system that’s owned and dominated by a handful of huge corporations.”

The above comments made by Smith, Roberts and Miller on RT television are completely factual and are views shared by tens of millions of fellow Americans. Rather than attempting to censor their well-founded arguments that America is dangerously headed in the wrong direction, perhaps we should get to work on the critical problems they are attempting to bring to the fore.




Trump's Carrier Deal: Job Saver Or Photo Op?


The closure of another plant in leaving some workers in other parts of Indiana feeling abandoned again, says Workers' Project Executive Director Tom Lewandowski





Jill Stein: Making Voting System More Credible is the First Step Towards Democratization


The former Green Party presidential candidate says razor-thin margins, unexpected outcomes, and use of unreliable voting machines prompted her to follow through with a campaign promise to stand for election integrity





Shady Submarine Deal Ties Netanyahu to Another Corrupt Scandal, Threatens Israeli-Germany Ties


The German arms company ThyssenKrupp pushed enormously expensive weapons on Greece while Germany was imposing austerity on the nation, says political economist Shir Hever





Why Chomsky and Zizek are wrong on the US elections



Chomsky and Zizek clashed on voting in the US elections, but the views of both are critically flawed.





Matt Damon from Howard Zinn's speech: The Problem is Civil Obedience